Addressing concerns of electric vehicle (EV) expansion is like
battling the nine heads of Hydra. The moment you think you’ve conquered
one, two sprout up in its place.
EV-related subjects cascade into a kaleidoscope of discussions, from
road maintenance (if EV owners buy no gas, they aren’t paying the
associated highway taxes) to rare earth mining in Mongolia (batteries
require lithium, the extraction of which raises both humanitarian and
environmental concerns). But one paramount concern continues to pop
up—infrastructure.
The argument goes something like this: How will such an enormous
network of charging stations be built? More important, who will pay?
Regarding the latter, it’s not unusual to hear the argument that
government must fund charging infrastructure in order to make it viable
for users to purchase EVs. But that’s not the case, or so we’ve learned
from the forward-thinking Kansas City Power and Light (KCP&L).
Yes, you heard correctly. Forward-thinking. Utility company. Kansas.
In 2015, KCP&L put down $20 million to install 1,000 charging
stations throughout its service territory of more than 800,000
customers. This was despite the fact that, at the time, there were only
about 1,600 plug-in electric vehicles in the entire state, a quarter of
them in the immediate Kansas City area.
Less than two years later, the utility had not only met its goal; it had exceeded it.
Today, there are more than 1,000 KCP&L-branded charging stations
up and running in places like grocery stores, apartment complexes, and
malls. In classic “if you build it, they will come” style, availability
of charging infrastructure rapidly spurred EV uptake. The area
straddling the Kansas-Missouri border is now one of the fastest-growing
EV markets in the nation.
With one of the biggest barriers to EV acceptance out of the way, consumers came rushing in. And it all took place without a government mandate or dinging an unwilling taxpayer.
It’s not that KCP&L didn’t consult the government or attempt to
pass along some of the cost to the public. It’s just that when the
utility asked the Kansas state legislature for a boost in the form of a
two- to three-cent monthly fee added to all customers’ bills, the
response was a flat-out “no.” On the other side of the state line,
Missouri legislators also nixed the request.
“Let the private sector invest in the EV market, rather than have
ratepayers finance the speculative venture,” the Kansas Corporation
Commission ruled.
That didn’t stop KCP&L. They simply footed the entire bill themselves.
According to KCP&L’s Chuck Caisley, the utility’s nuclear- and
wind-driven power grid is underutilized most of the time. Getting more
people to use more electricity improves efficiency of the
infrastructure, which drives down KCP&L’s per-unit cost. And that
means lower bills for all consumers.
The result is a win all around. The Kansas utility removed
roadblocks, consumers kept their right to choose, and no one had to
submit to government edicts. Best of all, in Kansas, EV drivers are
actually helping lower costs across the entire grid while doing their
carbon-reducing part.
This story signals how well-positioned utilities are to help quickly
transform the EV market, a fact that even environmental watchdogs,
notoriously tough on utilities, are taking notice of.
As Max Baunhefner of the Natural Resources Defense Council told
Stateline writer Martha T. Moore, “Utilities may not be the most
innovative companies in the world, but they are good at deploying boring
electrical infrastructure that doesn’t break. That’s what EV drivers
want and it’s sorely lacking at this point.”
Although KCP&L was an early success story, it’s not the only one.
In the United States, getting into the charging business has become a
coast-to-coast strategy for power companies.
The California Public Utilities Commission gave the nod to proposals
by three of the state’s largest utilities—Pacific Gas and Electric,
Southern California Edison, and San Diego Gas & Electric
(SDG&E)—to build more than 12,500 public charging stations for about
$200 million.
In Kentucky, Louisville Gas and Electric and Kentucky Utilities have
gotten the green light to build as many as twenty charging stations, the
cost to be recouped by collecting $3 an hour from the motorists who use
them.
New Jersey got into the act, too, thanks to a pilot program by Public
Service Electric & Gas (PSE&G) that installs charging stations
at customer locations around the state.
Back in Kansas, KCP&L’s Clean Charge Network chargers are a
popular fixture around town, not surprising given that the metro area
experienced 78 percent growth in EV adoption between 2016 and 2017. That
was more than any other city, including green hot spots such as Los
Angeles, Denver, and Durham.
The future is here in Kansas City, and the town is embracing it. And,
to trot out another Kansas trope, it didn’t take an omniscient, Oz-like
government wizard to make it happen. Pull back the curtain of subsidies
and schemes, let the open market run the show, and a grey and cloudy EV
picture opens up in living Technicolor